Some great men become greater the more they are studied; I should mention Spinoza and Lincoln as instances. Napoleon, on the other hand, becomes, at close quarters, a ridiculous figure.
Source: How to Read and Understanding History; the past as the key to the future.(Girard, kansas, Haldeman-Julius, 1943, 24 p. 22 cm.) Repr. in: Understanding History, and Other Essays, 1957.
A Brief Comment: Trump and Napoleon
Although their historical reputations differ greatly, Donald Trump and Napoleon appear to share a number of striking similarities in terms of their political behavior and the way they mobilized support. Of course, Napoleon Bonaparte succeeded in securing broad popular support and was able to stabilize society while rebuilding state institutions. Trump, by contrast, seems largely unconcerned about national division and shows little inclination to rescue the poor through institutional means. In this respect, there is a significant difference between the two.That said, setting aside these differences in social policy and national integration for the moment, I posed a simpler question to ChatGPT: Are there not, after all, some notable similarities between Trump and Napoleon?
ChatGPT’s Response
Comparisons between U.S. President Donald Trump and Napoleon Bonaparte (as well as Louis-Napoleon) have frequently been discussed by political commentators and historians. In fact, Trump himself once sparked controversy by likening himself to Napoleon in a social media post.Such comparisons point to several similarities and differences between the two figures.
Similarities
Populist foundations
Both rose to power by capitalizing on popular discontent with established political elites and existing power structures.
Preference for strong leadership
Just as Napoleon sought to impose order on post-revolutionary chaos through a strong central government, Trump promoted an “America First” agenda and displayed a tendency toward assertive use of executive power.
Use of media and public opinion
Napoleon carefully manipulated information to enhance his public image, and Trump likewise made direct appeals to the public through social media in an effort to shape his own image.
Unconventional methods
Both are noted for employing unorthodox tactics that defy traditional political and diplomatic norms.
Differences
Military background
Napoleon was an outstanding military commander who personally led troops on the battlefield, whereas Trump has no military career or experience.
Impact on state institutions
Napoleon left behind tangible achievements, most notably the reconstruction of the French state and legal system through the Napoleonic Code. By contrast, assessments of Trump’s political achievements remain deeply divided.
Capacity for political integration
Some commentators argue that Napoleon was able to present a unifying vision that transcended parties and social classes, whereas Trump tended instead to deepen domestic divisions.
In this way, comparisons between Trump and Napoleon are often used as a historical lens through which to analyze Trump’s political style, though evaluations of such comparisons vary widely depending on the observer.
 ラッセル関係電子書籍一覧 |
ラッセル関係電子書籍一覧
#Bertrand_Russell